A Wisconsin Supper Club Rush Inspired Meyer Cocktail Co.'s Better Old Fashioned
The woman and veteran-owned company makes the Old Fashioned mix bars kept asking for, including a sugar-free version that doesn't give up flavor.
SHEBOYGAN COUNTY, WI - Nov. 13, 2026 At a Wisconsin supper club, the busiest nights put every bartender to the same test: make the Old Fashioned fast, and make it taste like the last one. Cheri Meyer saw that test up close at her family's supper club, and it became the start of Meyer Cocktail Co.
"This brand was built on our family's Wisconsin supper club, where we had to expedite cocktails quickly during busy events without sacrificing quality," Meyer said. "We experienced firsthand how hard it was to keep drinks consistent under pressure. So we created a better way."
Then a customer gave her the push.
"One customer told me, 'I need something with a longer shelf life and a sugar-free option. But everything sacrifices flavor,'" Meyer said. "That's exactly why we built Meyer Cocktail Company."
Today the woman-and veteran-owned company makes a Signature Old Fashioned Mix, a Sugar Free Old Fashioned Mix and a Demerara syrup, so a bar or a host at home can pour the same Old Fashioned every time.
"Unlike traditional mixers or bulk ingredient suppliers, we don't just sell ingredients. We deliver a finished, repeatable cocktail experience," Meyer said. "For bars, that means faster service and lower labor costs. For consumers, that means a perfect Old Fashioned every single time."
Meyer Cocktail Co. was one of the companies in the Startups Built Simply Consumer Packaged Goods (CPG) Accelerator, a six-week program run in partnership with the Sheboygan County Economic Development Corporation (SCEDC). The biggest shift was in how Meyer talks about her product. She came in selling flavor. She left selling what a bar needs most on a busy night: less labor, less waste and the same drink every time, with the sugar-free mix as a standout.
"The partnership between SCEDC and Startups Built Simply is designed to help entrepreneurs move beyond great ideas and build sustainable businesses," said Ray York, Business Counselor for the Sheboygan County Economic Development Corporation and the Small Business Development Center at UW–Green Bay. "Founders like Cheri Meyer are solving real customer problems while building companies with strong potential to grow in Wisconsin and beyond."
Next, Meyer is taking the mixes to more bars and stores across the region and backing them with in-store sampling, a plan built on what she has already seen.
"We've already proven that when people taste the product, they buy," Meyer said.
Just in time for Thanksgiving Eve, one of the busiest bar nights of the year, and the holiday season, Meyer Cocktail Co.'s Old Fashioned mixes (18),Demerarasyrup(14) and the Ultimate Meyer Brothers Bundle ($45) are available at www.meyercocktailco.com, where a "Find Meyer Near You" map shows where to buy locally.
About Meyer Cocktail Co.
Meyer Cocktail Co. is a Wisconsin-based, woman- and veteran-owned beverage company making Old Fashioned mixes and cocktail syrups with a supper club soul. Rooted in the Meyer family's supper club, the company helps bars and home hosts pour a consistent, high-quality Old Fashioned every time, including a sugar-free option that keeps the flavor. Learn more at www.meyercocktailco.com.
About Startups Built Simply
Startups Built Simply helps entrepreneurs build scalable businesses through practical education, mentorship, and implementation-focused accelerator programs. Its Consumer Packaged Goods (CPG) Accelerator equips founders with the tools to strengthen positioning, improve operations, refine financial models, and prepare for sustainable business growth.